Organizational Development Interventions
Intervention involves identification of a set of activities, interaction are initiate that we serves as the most appropriate means for reaching the stated goals and objectives of the change strategy in the organization development. These interventions are also used to foster the ability to learn on the part of the target group. Furthermore, it includes all activities that take place between planning and evaluation stages of program development. These intervention may include executing coaching and counseling, team building restructuring of the organization training and development of the members of the organization etc. choice of intervention has to be made at every stage of the change process from and unfreezing and refreezing.
Various phases of intervention
The initial phase of unfreezing involves assessment of the current status, problem identification, diagnosis, and choice of appropriate change strategy. For achieving this, the OD consultants make use a variety of interventions like survey feedback, administration of specially designed instruments, brainstorming sessions, focused group discussion and interviews, besides accessing information from secondary sources. Based on diagnosis of the problems, the suitable change strategy is selected and adapted. The change strategy may involve the target group such as total organization, its units, individual employs or other internal stakeholders. The strategy would also include a set intervention targeted at enabling the target group move towards a desirable features state of the organizational change.
In the moving phase appropriate intervention to implement the change strategy are decided upon. That target group or groups are actively engaged in choosing the intervention as they are better informed about the feasibility and ease of exhaustion. The choice of intervention would largely depend upon a variety of factors like the problem being encountered, change goals that have been set and the target group’s level of commitment to the change.
The refreezing phase focuses on helping members of the target group internalize the changes through attitudinal restructuring, behavioral modification and developing appropriate mental models. Supportive mechanism for reinforcement of change paradigms, attitudes and behaviors are developed. These reinforcement mechanisms may involve restructuring of policies, systems, processes and structure of the organization. Unexpected problems and unintended consequences of intervention are identified and adequately dealt with. It is also essential to evaluate the effectiveness of change strategy which may lead to design of further intervention.
This model is known as kurt Lewin’s three step change model intervention.
Decision Criteria of OD Interventions
Choice of interventions will depend on the extent to which they fit the needs of the client organizations, the degree to which they are based on the intended outcomes and the extent to which change management competencies can be transferred to organization members. The target group of change –individual group or organization will also have to be considered for the feasibility and relevance of particular set of interventions. More specifically, the decision criteria to be considered will include the following:
• Result – driven:
T0 what extent the intervention is directed towards achievement of change goal? What will be the potential results of the intervention?
• Problem- centric:
Will the intervention solve the problem already identified?
• Consequences:
Are there additional positive outcomes that are likely to result? What are the likely positive and? Or negative fallouts in terms of consequences.
• Implementation Potential:
To what extent the intervention in question can be implemented smoothly? Can it head to its logical conclusion? What are the constraints likely to be encountered in the implementation process? Is that a plan for dealing with the constraint set?
• Cost Benefit Analysis:
What are the central costs and human costs involved? What will be the impact of costs on the client system? To what extent will the benefits in terms of expected results and their consequences outweigh the direct and indirect costs?
• Acceptability:
To what extent is the client organization likely to accept the intervention? Will it have a wider acceptance among the target group members?
• Credibility:
Does the intervention enjoy high credibility? Has it been adequately tested and validated? How well has it worked in other organization in achieving change goals without causing undue disturbance in the system.
• Shard Ownership:
Has the intervention been adequately explained and communicated to members of the client organization? Is there a shared ownership of the intervention by the consultant and the client target group?
Implementation of Intervention
After having made a choice of intervention, it is important to develop appropriate implementation strategy to ensure its successfully execution. Implementation strategy must have built-in flexibility to accommodate any variation in the change plan, bee adaptable to changed conditions, extent of goal attainment and unanticipated consequences, if any. Implementation of intervention is a learning experience subject to continuous refinement. Interventions can take many forms depending on the problem that the client group is trying to solve. Effective implementation will depend on the following factors:
A. An intervention strategy must be formulated with clearly stated long – term and short – term goals and objectives of change.
B. Activities to promote learning and change should be structured effectively, this is achieved by keeping the following point in mind:
• All relevant people should be included. Client groups should identify problems and opportunities themselves and generate solutions to their own problems and utilize the potential inherent in their own opportunities. The goals and strategies for goal attainment must be clearly stated and shared with very client group.
• Activities should be structured in such a way that there is a high probability of success. Goals therefor must be manageable and attainable. Positive feedback regarding success in goal attainment can work as powerful motivation for the client group.
• The existing climate in the organization should be such as to facilitate the implementation of a particular intervention. In case, the client group is defensive and anxious, additional interventions for creating a climate conductive to achievement of changed goals must be through of.
• The focus should not only b on learning how to solve one particular problem but on “learning how to learn.” This is achieved by helping the client groups acquire and sharpen such skills and knowledge as are desirable for solving future problems and managing change. The intervention should involve not only the process that is how of the problem but also the content that is, what of the problem.
• It is necessary to engage the “whole person” in intervention not just the rational/ logical part of him but also his emotional and spiritual self. It is important that the intervention facilitates members of the client group to openly express and confront their thoughts, feelings, concerns, beliefs, assumptions and the paradigm.
• Conceptual mode of learning as also experiential learning should be included in the intervention.
C. Intervention activities and their sequencing must be don carefully based on the following criteria.
• Interventions must be based on sufficient diagnostic data representing the full facts from multiple perspectives. Insufficient data can lead to inappropriate interventions. Multiple sources of data are often used to ensure in depth- analysis of the problems.
• Interventions used in the initial phase of the change programme should enhance the effectiveness of subsequent intervention. The interventions aimed at building motivation, preparedness, knowledge and competencies required for future change should come first. Experiential learning to sensitize members of the target group with different needs, attitudes and behavior with each other should precede other interventions for conflict resolution between individuals and groups. Sequencing of interventions should be done to maximize efficiency by conserving time, energy and money.
• Delay in achieving organizational improvement could lead to loss of momentum and motivation. There is a need therefor to maximize the speed of intervention programs so that pre-specified milestones could be achieved.
• The related interventions to immediate problems should be taken up first so as to establish relevance to organization issues.
• Sequencing of interventions should be done to provide psychological safety to members of the target group. The choice of intervention should be such that it reduces anxiety and disillusionment likely to arise due to uncertainties, inherent in any change effort.
Results of OD intervention
OD interventions are designed to accomplish specific change objectives. However, in the process of achieving these objectives, the interventions also contribute to inculcation of certain values in the client organization. Thus the possible results of OD interventions are as follows:
• Greater degree of transparency in the system coupled with open exchange or feedback
• Enhanced awareness of changing socio- cultural milieu and dysfunctional nature of norms currently prevalent in the organization
• High interchange of ideas, opinions and information through increased interaction and communication
• A culture that encourages science based knowledge , concepts, competencies and attitudes derived from OD values
• Increased participation in goal setting, problem solving and brainstorming
• Heightened sense of accountability through responsibility allocation, authority delineation and performance monitoring
• Increased optimism regarding desirable regarding desirable futures and release of energy in pursuit of its attainment
Categories and techniques of Interventions
Several OD interventions, also called techniques, have evolved over time. The most successful of them possess three key characteristics:
(i) They are based on valid information about the functioning of the organization, usually collected by the employees;
(ii) The intervention (under the guidance of the change agent) provides employees with opportunities to make their own choices regarding the nature of the problems and their preferred solutions; and
(iii) Interventions are aimed at gaining the employees personal commitment to their choices.
The number and variety of OD techniques have substantially increased over the past decade. A wide range of intervention is now available to the managers. The four categories of interventions available for the organizational development are:
a. Human Processes Interventions:
The OD techniques in this category are aimed at improving the employees’ interpersonal skills. The purpose is to provided them with the inside and skills needed to analyze effectively their own and other’s behavior so that they can intelligently solve interpersonal and inter group problems. Perhaps the most widely used technique is called sensitivity training. This sensitivity training is also called the T-Group training. This is one of the earliest techniques and is still in use. The objective of this training is to provide the employees with increased awareness of their own behavior and how others perceive them. Greater sensitivity to the behavior of others and the increased understanding of the group processes are fundamental to this technique. Specific results sought from sensitivity training include:
• Increased ability to empathize with others.
• Improved listening skills.
• Greater openness.
• Increased tolerance of individual differences.
• Improved conflict resolution skills.
Being highly personal in nature this has become a controversial technique and has diminished in use in the last 20 years. This can definitely be a dangerous exercise if led by an inadequately prepared trainer.
b. Team building Intervention:
Team building is a process of diagnosing and improving the effectiveness of a work group with particular attention to work procedures and interpersonal relationships within it, especially, the role of the leader in relation to other group members. Both the group’s task procedures and its human interaction are the subjects of study in team building. The basic assumption of tam building is that increasing effectiveness of tams will improve the organization’s overall effectiveness.
Team building can be directed at two different types of teams of working groups: first, an existing or permanent team made up of manager and his subordinates, often called family group; and second, a new group which may have been created through a merger or other structural change in the organization, or formed to solve a specific problem, which may be called the special group. For both kinds of groups, tam building activities aim at diagnosing barriers to effective team performance, improving task accomplishments, improving relationships among team members, and improving processes operative in the team such as communication and task assignment. It will suffice for the student to know the simple description of this intervention. Details of team building concepts have already been dealt elsewhere in this book to which the student can refer to enrich the understanding of the team building exercise.
c. Grid Training:
Grid organizational development, an extension of the managerial grid concept developed by Blake and Mouton (also rad chapter on Leadership), is usually carried out on an organization wide basis. Grid training seeks to promote organizational excellence by fostering concern for production and concern for people. Working on the premise that most organizational problems stem from poor communication and inadequate planning, Blake and Mouton proposed a multistep process for improving organizations by attempting to cultivate these skills.
This is given to briefly explain the intervention to the student. The details of grid training and its ramifications are being separately given in one of the subsequent units of this book material. The student will have to read that to have a complete inside into this technique.
d. Techno - Structural Intervention:
Experts in OD are increasingly relying on efforts to change the structures, methods, and job designs of organizations. As compared with human process interventions, such techno- structural interventions ( as well as the human resource management interventions and strategic interventions described later) generally utilize the traditional OD action research approach, but focus more directly on productivity improvement and efficiency.
OD practitioners use a variety of techno structural interventions. For example, the formal structure change involves having the employees collect data on existing formal structures and analyze the details. The purpose is to jointly redesign and implement new organizational structures. OD experts also use the employee involvement programs like quality circles, TOM, and quality of work life programs.
It is interesting to understand the TOM- Total Quality Management – approach to develop customer centric cultures as the organizational response to changing expectation of the customers. The objective of the TQM is to create a total quality organization and not nearly provide quality products and service to its customers. Total quality thus applies to all those who affect and are affected by the organization which includes suppliers, employees, wholesalers, retailers, shareholders and so on. The quality should become a way of life reflected in all of the activities of the organization. All members of the organization and groups should exhibit its manifestation. TQM dries and ongoing continuous process which requires radical change in the organization design and day-to-day operations.
To that end, wide variety of interventions and organization improvement techniques and approaches like statistical process control, statistical quality control, quality circles, self- management team and task forces are employed.
1. Customer-driven. Methods, processes, and procedures are designed to meet both internal and external customer expectations.
2. Leadership. Top management fully understands the quality process and supports the strategy through both words and deeds.
3. Full participation. Everyone in the organization is provided quality training. From top to bottom, everyone has the perspective, goals, and the necessary tools and techniques for improving quality.
4. Reward system. There is a system in place that rewards quality to ensure continual support for the overall effort.
5. Reduced cycle time. There is a strong effect to reduce the cycle times, in product or service output as well as support functions, following the maxim “if it cannot be done any better, focus on doing it faster.”
6. Prevention, not detection. Quality is designed into the product or service, so that errors are prevented from occurring rather than being detected and then corrected.
7. Management by fact. Managers use data- based feedback to measure progress; intuition and gut feel are put on the back burner.
8. Long-range outlook. There is a constant monitoring of the external environment in order to answer the question: what level of quality or service will have to be provided to customers over the next 12 to 36 months, and how can this goal be attained?
9. Partnership development. The organization promotes cooperation with vendors as well as customers, thus developing a network system that helps drive up quality and hold down costs.
10. Public responsibility. Corporate citizenship and responsibility are fostered by sharing quality- related information with other organizations and by working to reduce negative impacts on the community by eliminating product waste generation and product defects or recalls.
Thus, it is obvious that, to implement TQM the organization needs to bring about change in its organizational culture. TOM is a philosophy of management encompassing virtually all aspects of management policies, systems, structures and practices. It requires active support of the top management as also high degree of employee involvement. This intervention has been used extensively in practically all lading public and private sectors and organizations in India with varying degree of success.
e. Quality of Work Life Program Intervention:
QWL programs have been designed by OD practitioners to create work situations that enhance employee’s motivation, satisfaction and commitment factors that may contribute to high levels of organizational performance. Collectively called quality of work life programs, this intervention is designed to remove drudgery associate with any work situation. In other words, this attempts to humanize the work place.
Simply, a definition of QWL has been given here as the same subject will be dealt in detail in a subsequent chapter of this book.
f. Human Resource Management Interventions:
Human resource management practices such as hiring, training, and performance appraisal can mould employee commitment, motivations, and productivity. OD practitioners are , therefore, increasingly involved in using action research to enable employees to analyze and change their firm’s personnel practices. Targets of change include the firm’s appraisal system, reward system, and workforce diversity programs.
g. Strategic Interventions:
There have been constant additions to the basket of OD techniques. The newest addition is the integrated strategic management. This approach consist of four steps:
(i) Analyzing current strategy and organization design. Managers and other employees utilize models such as SWOT matrix to analyze the firm’s current strategy, as well as its organization design.
(ii) Choosing a desired strategy and organization design. Based on the OD consultant- assigned analysis, senior management formulates a strategic vision, strategic objectives, a strategic plan, and an organization structure for implementing them.
(iii) Designing a strategic change plan. The group designs a strategic change plan, which is an action plan for moving the organization from its current strategy and design to the desired future strategy and design. It explains how the strategic change will be implemented, including thee specific activities involved as well as the costs and budgets associated with them.
(iv) Implementing a strategic change plan. The final step involves actually implementing the strategic change plan and measuring and reviewing the results of the change activities to ensure that the process is proceeding as planned.
Summary
It is evident from the description of various interventions presented about that OD adopts a multidimensional approach to plant change in any organization. It encompasses a wild range of tools and techniques derived from behavioral sciences theories and research to address the concerns all kinds of organization irrespective of their stages of growth, size, volume, complexity. Large group inventions like search conferences, learning organizations and appreciative inquiry are being adopted to enable organization develop changeability, and preparedness to activities in turbulent and often chaotic environment. OD makes use of a variety of interventions to achieve change goals. Choice of intervention has to make at every stage of the change process. The valuation of effectiveness of OD intervention is carried out on a containing basis for mid- course correction.
The subject of OD interventions is vast and unending. The information given in this chapter will be sufficient to enable student to face any examination question. However for a very through and total understanding of the subject the students will have to refer a number of reference books to sharpen their own knowledge of this subject.